Blog··9 min read·By Nitzan Gribetz

Interpolation vs Sample: What Each One Costs

Interpolation vs sample: one re-plays the part, the other lifts the audio. What each one needs cleared, and the writing share you hand over.

Rows of blue royalty bars rising over a deep navy field — generated artwork for this article

Interpolation vs sample comes down to one question: did you use the original audio, or did you play the part again yourself? If the old recording is in your track, it is a sample. If somebody re-played or re-sang the part in your session, it is an interpolation. That single fact decides who you have to ask for permission, and the difference is not small: a sample needs two clearances, an interpolation needs one.

The US Copyright Office puts the line in the same place. Sampling means taking part of an existing sound recording and putting it in a new work. An interpolation means taking part of an existing musical work, the melody or the lyric, and recording new audio of it.

Why the clearance is different

Every song you hear is two copyrights stacked on top of each other. There is the composition, which is the melody, the chords and the words, owned by writers and their publishers. There is the recording, which is one fixed performance of that composition, usually owned by a label or by whoever paid for the session.

Use the audio and you have touched both. The recording is obvious, and the composition rides along inside it, which is why sample clearance means two negotiations with two owners who are often unrelated companies.

Re-play the part and you have touched only the composition. This is not a courtesy or an industry custom, it is written into the statute. Section 114(b) of the Copyright Act says the sound recording owner's rights "do not extend to the making or duplication of another sound recording that consists entirely of an independent fixation of other sounds, even though such sounds imitate or simulate those in the copyrighted sound recording." The Copyright Office reads it the way it sounds: permission from the recording owner is not needed when you interpolate, regardless of how similar your new recording ends up being to the old one.

So a producer who nails a four-bar replay has removed the label from the conversation entirely. What is left is the publisher, and the publisher is the expensive half.

Neither one has a price list

People assume there is a rate card somewhere. There is not, and this is where the comparison to a cover misleads people.

A cover re-records a whole song, and US law hands you a compulsory mechanical license for that: meet its conditions and the owner cannot normally say no, and the statutory rate is set for you. The Copyright Office is clear about the limit of that license, though. An arrangement made under it "cannot change the basic melody or fundamental character of the work."

Dropping somebody's hook into a song of your own is not a cover and does not qualify. It is a new work that borrows, which means there is no compulsory anything. The publisher can refuse, or agree, or name a number, and the number depends on how badly they think you need it.

What an interpolation actually costs

Two songs that interpolate the same catalog show the spread.

Ariana Grande's "7 Rings" reworks "My Favorite Things" from The Sound of Music. Billboard reported, confirming the New York Times, that Richard Rodgers and Oscar Hammerstein II control 90% of the track's songwriting royalties, paid through Concord, which has owned that catalog since 2017. Grande's representatives brought the finished song to Concord weeks before release, Concord asked for 90%, and they took it. Eight other credited writers, Grande included, divide the remaining tenth.

Gwen Stefani's "Wind It Up" interpolates "The Lonely Goatherd" from the same musical. On that one the Rodgers and Hammerstein side took 50%.

What mattersSampleInterpolation
What you useThe original audioA re-recorded part
Recording ownerMust clear itNo say, per section 114(b)
PublisherMust clear itMust clear it
Statutory rateNoneNone
Usual price shapeFee, sometimes plus a shareA permanent share of your song

Read the bottom row twice, because it is the row that gets skipped. A sample is often bought. An interpolation is usually rented forever: the share sits on the composition for as long as the copyright lasts, and it applies to every stream, every sync and every cover of your song, not just the version you are about to release.

The one case where interpolation is actually free

Public domain is the exception that is worth knowing precisely, because half of it is free and half of it is not.

When copyright in a composition has expired, you can interpolate it without asking anybody. That is why the melody Nas interpolated on "I Can", Beethoven's "Für Elise", needs nobody's permission: copyright in that composition expired long ago. The recording is a separate copyright with its own clock, so lifting the audio from a modern recording of "Für Elise" needs clearance even though the music itself is centuries old.

The Copyright Office uses the same example in reverse: you may copy or interpolate Grieg's "In the Hall of the Mountain King" freely, and you may not sample The Offspring's recording of it.

One more thing nobody can charge you for: scales, chords and arpeggios. Common building blocks are not owned, and short musical phrases are not protected on their own.

There is no safe number of seconds

The seven-second rule does not exist. The Copyright Office answers it with the word "fiction," because fair use is decided case by case and no fixed amount of a work is automatically safe. The same page dismisses the other studio myth: writing "no copyright infringement intended" in a description protects nothing, since infringement does not require intent.

If you are deciding whether to clear something, the length of the borrowed part is a weak signal. Whether it is the recognizable part is a much stronger one.

The part that decides whether you get paid

Here is the step that gets lost, and it is the step we see fail most often. Clearing an interpolation is not the end of the work. It changes who the writers on your song are, and your registrations have to say so.

Once a deal is signed, the original writers are writers on your record. Rodgers and Hammerstein are credited among the ten songwriters on "7 Rings," not thanked in the liner notes. That means your work registration at your PRO and at The MLC has to carry their names, their IPI numbers and their shares, and your side has to add up to what is actually left.

When it does not, nothing bounces back with a helpful error. Say the publisher registers its 90% while you register 100% of your own: the song now has 190% claimed against it. Both claims sit in dispute and the money stops moving until somebody fixes the filing. The songwriters we administer have 22,000+ songs between them, and a borrowed part that the registration does not reflect is one of the quieter ways a song earns nothing while looking perfectly fine on streaming.

Two habits prevent all of it. Put the cleared share on a split sheet the day the deal closes, while the numbers are still in an email you can find. Then make sure the registration matches that sheet rather than the demo version of the credits. If you bought the instrumental from a beat store, check the same thing one layer down, because the producer's own splits and any sample inside the beat are your problem once the song is yours.

Our opinion: the cheap clearance is the riskier release

Interpolation gets sold to independent writers as the easy way around sample clearance. One owner instead of two, no label legal department, a producer who can replay anything in an afternoon. All true, and it is still the option we would warn you about harder.

Two reasons. The first is leverage. With a sample, you usually find out early that you cannot afford it, because the label says no and there is no record to release. With an interpolation, nothing stops you finishing the song. Content ID matches audio fingerprints against reference recordings, so a part your producer played again is not the thing it is built to find. A distributor will not catch it either. You can put out an uncleared interpolation, get a modest hit, and only then discover that the publisher has every incentive to let the stream count climb before answering your email. Concord asked Grande for 90% with a finished record in hand. Your leverage is worst at exactly the moment the song starts working.

The second is the shape of the bill. A one-time fee is survivable. A permanent 50% of the writing on your best song is a different thing, and it follows that song into every deal you ever do with it.

None of which means do not interpolate. It means decide before you record, not after you release, and treat a four-bar replay as the business decision it is rather than a production choice. If you cannot get an answer from the publisher, write around it. A song you own outright is worth more than a better song you own a third of.

How Davincii fits

We register compositions, which means we see the aftermath of these deals rather than negotiate them. Davincii does not clear samples or interpolations, and we would be suspicious of any administrator that claimed to for a commission on royalties.

What we do is the filing that makes a cleared deal pay. We register your works at your PRO and at The MLC with the writers, the IPI numbers and the shares the agreement actually gave, so your own percentage is claimed cleanly and the original publisher's is not contested by accident. Where a share on a filed registration is already wrong, correcting it is ordinary work for us rather than an exception.

There is no upfront fee, you keep your copyright, and we are paid a commission on what we collect. If you want the mechanics first, start with how registration works or the difference between the writer share and the publisher share.

Common questions

What is the difference between an interpolation and a sample?

A sample takes part of an existing sound recording and drops that audio into a new track. An interpolation takes part of an existing composition, the melody or the lyric, and records it again from scratch. The US Copyright Office draws the line at the audio: interpolating a musical work does not involve using any of the actual sounds from a previous recording, because new audio is recorded instead.

Do you need permission for an interpolation?

Yes, from the publisher and writers of the original composition. What you do not need is permission from whoever owns the original recording. Section 114(b) of the Copyright Act says the rights in a sound recording do not extend to another recording made of independently fixed sounds, even where those sounds imitate the copyrighted one. So the label is out of the conversation and the publisher is the whole conversation.

Is an interpolation cheaper than a sample?

The clearance is simpler, since there is one owner to find instead of two, and one of the two is usually the slower one. Cheaper is a different question. Both are negotiated with no statutory rate, and the price of an interpolation is normally a permanent share of the new song's writing rather than a one-time fee, which can cost far more over a catalog's life than a buyout would have.

Is an interpolation the same as a cover?

No. A cover re-records a whole song, and US law gives you a compulsory mechanical license for that, so the owner cannot refuse. An interpolation puts part of an existing song inside a new one, which is a different request: there is no compulsory license for it, and the publisher can say no or name any number it likes.

Can you interpolate a public domain song for free?

The composition, yes, once copyright in it has expired. The recording is a separate question. You can re-play a public domain melody without clearing anything, but you cannot lift the audio from a modern recording of that same melody, because that recording carries its own copyright. This is the one case where interpolating and sampling have genuinely different price tags rather than different paperwork.

How many seconds can you sample without clearing it?

There is no such number. The Copyright Office calls the seven-second rule fiction outright, because fair use is decided case by case and no fixed amount of a work is automatically safe. A disclaimer saying no infringement is intended changes nothing either, since infringement does not require intent.

What happens to my splits when an interpolation is cleared?

The original writers become credited writers on your song, at whatever share the deal set, and your registrations have to say so. Rodgers and Hammerstein are credited among the ten songwriters on 7 Rings. If your work registration at your PRO and at The MLC still shows 100% to you, the paperwork contradicts the deal, which is how a song ends up with a conflicting claim and a payment that stops moving.

Nitzan Gribetz

Independent songwriter publishing administration, based in Brooklyn NY.

Want this for your catalog?

Davincii registers your songs domestically and internationally — paid only from what we collect.

Get started